On Saturday evening, Star Trek: Prelude to Axanar premiered outside the San Diego Comic-Con. This fan film was founded via Kickstarter and is a prequel (of sorts) to the primary project, Star Trek: Axanar.
The story involves a History Channel-like show that is giving the set-up to the famed Battle of Axanar. During the first major war the United Federation of Planets fought, they were losing. The Klingon Empire, both threatened and unimpressed with the Federation, had decided to launch an invasion. After more than a year of success, the Federation, reeling from continued losses, changed tact. Aside from shake-ups in the command structure, more daring strategies were combined with an arms races with between the galactic powers. Due to Klingon’s arrogance, their gains were reversed- though they were not beaten nor dissuaded. The film ends with the premise of forcing a battle that would end the war, one way or the other.
The cast for Prelude is small- only a handful of characters were relaying their stories to the historical production. However, the pedigree of these actors, especially for what is essentially a fan-film, is quite stellar. The cast includes: Tony Todd (Star Trek: The Next Generation, Candyman) as Marcus Ramirez, Kate Vernon (Battlestar Galactica, Falcon Crest) as Sonya Alexander, Richard Hatch (Battlestar Galactica, The Streets of San Francisco) as General Kharn, J.G. Hertzler (Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, Zorro) as Samuel Travis, Gary Graham (Star Trek: Enterprise, Alien Nation) reprising his role from Enterprise as Ambassador Soval & Alec Peters as Garth of Izar. The experience of the casting shows through as well- this feels much closer to an independent film, or even a smaller studio production, than a fan film- though to be fair, the crew made a lot of this happen as well.
Of special notes are the special effects- vignettes of starships, both traveling and fighting, shown during the interviews to punctuate what the characters are relating. The quality of the CGI and the overall feel of the space shots reminds Trek fans of the motion pictures, (not the new JJ Abrams one, but the Prime Timeline movies). However, the fights felt a bit sedated- though this review believes that is due to only showing the exteriors of the fights, without inside the ship shots to show how the crew was reacting. It is presumed this missing element will be shown in the movie proper- but for a history show, (fictional or otherwise), it worked.
Other elements of the background worked as well. The script, while fairly bare bones, portrayed each character as a distinct personality; Captain Alexander is not interchangeable with Captain Travis, nor were Kharn and Rameriz mirror images. Further, the framing device of the history show felt mostly right- if I were to nitpick, the footage was a little too clean for material captured during a battle, even in the 22nd Century. The music was also understated, lending to an educational feel. Lastly, the lighting for the two interview rooms gave them a distinctly different feel, suiting the different affiliations and their settings quite well.
This reviewer does hope that the Axanar movie proper will address how the Federation could be beaten back so easily by the Klingons after a founding member, Earth, succeeded alone against another galactic power in the Earth-Romulan Wars. There seem to be four possibilities: 1) the ERW exhausted Earth and the Federation spent significant resources rebuilding the Terran infrastructure, leaving the Federation weakened; 2) the ERW was fought in a vastly significant way tactically, with Starfleet busy fighting the last war while the Klingons were not; 3) the Klingon Empire is simply vastly superior militarily to the Federation and the Romulan Star Empire, or 4) the ERW was a border war, and this was the first all-out interstellar war Earth and the Federation fought, whereas the Klingons fought them frequently. Without addressing this, (especially in the context of a historical look back), it will seem odd that the Four-Year War went so badly for the Federation, after a founding member held off another Star Empire independently.
(One minor detail that breaks from the Prime Timeline canon is the importance of Axanar: the movie concludes with Garth’s plan, using Axanar as bait. Part of the reason for this is the temptation of destroying the Federation’s newest ships, the Consitution-class starships, in construction over Axanar. Most notably, the USS Enterprise (NCC-1701) was shown among them- however, canonically, the Enterprise was constructed over Earth in the San Francisco Yards. But, if tiny details like this are your main problem, that’s pretty good. (And quite frankly, show a level of care and concern far above the recent Star Trek reboot movies.))
Lastly, there are some Easter Eggs included. I will leave them for you to find, save for this one: eagle-eyed Battlestar Galactica fans, was the first Federation ship shown and destroyed- the USS Triton, NCC-1439; (the Battlestar Triton, destroyed in the Colonial Holocaust, was designated BSG-39).
Overall, Star Trek: Prelude to Axanar is an impressive short film. Despite being an entirely independent project, it feels like it would easily have come out of the Paramount lot. And even though the entire film is essentially a framing device for the Axanar movie proper, it does its jobs and whets the appetite for more.
If you’re looking for the TL:DR version, if you are a Star Trek fan or enjoy good science fiction, definitely give Prelude to Axanar a watch once it become available to the general public at the end of July- you won’t regret it.
The Kickstarter for the main project, Star Trek: Axanar, went online this weekend and is, at this moment, over 90% funded. Given what they did for Prelude, I see the funding being reached- and the final product should be glorious… You can check it out Kickstarter- Star Trek: Axanar. In the meantime, while waiting for Prelude to Axanar to release, here is the preview.
Star Trek- Prelude to Axanar on IMDb